Numbers rise on strategic defaults by borrowers with negative equity
Numbers rise on strategic defaults by borrowers who believe it’s best for their finances
Homeowners have found themselves in foreclosure for a number of reasons.
Some purchased properties they could never really afford.
Others lost their jobs–the national unemployment rate remains in the double digits–and had no way to make mortgage payments.
But as the crisis rumbles forward, an additional driver of home foreclosures has become clear: Many borrowers have the means to keep paying the mortgage but are simply walking away because they believe it’s best for their finances.
Strategic defaults doubled
The number of so called “strategic defaults” more than doubled, to 588,000, from 2007 to 2008, according to a study by Experian and Oliver Wyman.
A separate 2009 survey found that more than a quarter of all existing defaults were strategic.
Many homeowners are using a little known DIY tactic guaranteed to stop the foreclosure process in less than a day to buy some time up to several months to work out a solution
Click here find out how to fight back against your lender with this strategy
Meanwhile, a growing number of academics are touting the financial benefits of walking away. “Homeowners should be walking away in droves,” Brent T. White, a University of Arizona law school professor, said in a recent paper. “The financial costs of foreclosure, while not insignificant, are minimal compared to the financial benefit of strategic default.”
Strategically defaulting is linked to negative equity
The case for strategically defaulting is linked to negative equity, or owing more on your home than it is worth. With home prices at the national level having dropped roughly 30 percent from their 2006 peaks—and a great deal more in certain bubble markets—a considerable chunk of property owners are now in this fix.
Nearly 1 in 4 borrowers currently have negative equity, according to First American CoreLogic. And rather than continuing to make payments on an investment that’s now worth significantly less than what they paid for it, many borrowers are throwing in the towel.
Example:
White uses the following example to demonstrate how many borrowers are better off defaulting: A young professional couple with two children pays $585,000 for a three-bedroom, Salinas, Calif.-home in January 2006.
At $4,300, monthly payments on their no-money-down, 30-year fixed mortgage with an interest rate of 6.5 percent represent a tad less than 31 percent of their gross monthly income. Toss in taxes, student loans, health care, food, and other essentials, and finances quickly get tight.
After the historic housing bust, their home is now worth $187,000, but they still owe $560,000.
Other homes in their neighborhood, of course, have plummeted in value as well. And if the couple was to purchase a similar, nearby house listed at $179,000, their monthly payments would be less than $1,200.
That’s a huge savings over their current $4,300 monthly mortgage bill. But since a foreclosure on their credit report is likely to prevent them from buying a home in the near-term, they may have to rent. And about $1,000 a month gets them a comparable rental property in their neighborhood.
$340,000 saved by walking away
“Assuming they intend to stay in their home ten years, [the homeowners] would save approximately $340,000 by walking away, including a monthly savings of at least $1,700 on rent verses mortgage payments, even after factoring in the mortgage interest tax reduction,” White writes.
“If they stay in their home, on the other hand, it will take [the homeowners] over 60 years just to recover their equity—assuming, of course, that they live that long.”
The argument against strategically defaulting is much more straightforward:
You promised to repay the loan when you took out the mortgage, and it’s your responsibility to do everything possible to honor that commitment.
Avoiding the guilt and shame that can accompany a foreclosure is one of the top reasons struggling homeowners don’t strategically default, White writes. On top of that, a foreclosure significantly damages one’s credit—making it difficult, if not impossible, to obtain a mortgage for years afterward.
But in a recent white paper, Alex Edmans, an assistant professor of finance The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania, argues that many homeowners are ignoring these consequences to do what they believe is in their best financial interest.
“Defaulting on their loan is a rational decision: While they forfeit their home, they rid themselves of a mortgage liability of even greater value,” Edmans writes. “The source of the problem is the homeowner’s balance sheet: since he has negative equity in his home, it is not worth keeping it by paying the mortgage.”
Negative equity a nasty headache for the Obama administration
The issue of negative equity triggering strategic defaults represents a nasty headache for the Obama administration. The $75 billion mortgage housing rescue the administration unveiled last February is designed to keep people in their homes by reducing their monthly mortgage payments down to more manageable levels.
The plan does not, however, require lenders or servicers to reduce borrowers’ mortgage principal—meaning underwater borrowers still have this incentive to walk away from their home loan.
Laurie Goodman, a senior managing director at Amherst Securities Group, considers negative equity to be the housing market’s greatest challenge and believes current housing rescue efforts are insufficient.
“The current modification program does not address negative equity, and is therefore destined to fail,” Goodman said in written testimony before a Congressional committee in December. “It must be amended to explicitly address this problem.”
Principal write-downs needed
Although Uncle Sam has reduced mortgage payments for more than 850,000 borrowers so far—for a median savings of more than $500—the government will remain under pressure to take more aggressive action as long as the foreclosure epidemic keeps churning.
Mark Zandi, the chief economist at Moody’s Economy.com, believes the government may take steps to tackle the issue of negative equity head-on this year by incorporating principal write downs—which reduce a borrower’s negative equity position—into the housing rescue program.
#####
Source: http://www.usnews.com/money/personal-finance/real-estate/articles/2010/01/19/strategic-defaults-and-the-foreclosure-crisis.html
Before letting a bank force you out of your home, you may want to obtain some coaching on how to stop the foreclosure process dead in its tracts and buy some time to make your next move
If you’re interested, you can check out the website for more information here
| Homeowners – Need Some Sound Advice? | |
 Get Out of Debt Workbook Seasoned debt expert shares several little known but highly effective techniques guaranteed to get you out of debt fast – no matter how much you currently owe. |
Loan Modification Get more help on fighting for your loan modification including tools and strategies, Q&As, how to qualify for the HAMP program, scam alerts and news on the latest loan modification efforts among the banks and government HAMP program. Legally Restore Your Credit |
strategic defaults, negative equity, principal reductions, principal write-downs, stop foreclosure, foreclosure help, avoid foreclosure, prevent foreclosure, foreclosure prevention
Technorati Tags: strategic defaults, negative equity, principal reductions, principal write-downs, stop foreclosure, foreclosure help, avoid foreclosure, prevent foreclosure, foreclosure prevention
Related posts:
- Rise in foreclosures prompting more banks to consider principal reductions Mounting foreclosures motivating banks to negotiate principal reductions in loan...
- Most loan modifications leave homeowners without equity and paying excessive housing costs Most home loan modifications leave homeowners without equity and paying...
- Interest rates are at historic lows but banks are resistant to refinance good borrowers Mortgage rates in the United States have dropped to their...
- The number of OC home loans in default continues to rise after more than three years OC home loan default rates continues to rise....
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.
Good post! I always appreciate being kept up to speed on these issues. Hollis Mandell PA. http://bit.ly/bYGKex